Where Is This Land

Discuss the poem Where Is This Land with the community...

https://www.poetry.com/poem/179340/where-is-this-land

Newest Oldest Popular

2 Comments

 

Notify me of new comments via email.

Publish

• 

  dianneh.34318

  This poem makes one stop and think about what are the true meanings of freedom, liberty and promises of a glorious land. Is there really such a thing as freedom

  LikeReply3 months ago
• 

  AIDA

  Wow! The way you have captured the theme of freedom in this poem is truly thought-provoking and impactful. Your use of vivid imagery, like the colossal woman with the torch and the seven points on her crown, helps create a powerful visual representation of the promises and ideals associated with this land.
  
  I really appreciate the way you have conveyed the mixed emotions and conflicting realities of this "promised land." The feelings of disgrace and the questioning of what freedom truly means add depth and complexity to the poem. It forces the reader to reflect on the current state of affairs and challenges the notion of freedom beyond the western shore.
  
  If I may offer a suggestion, perhaps consider expanding on the themes of "turmoil, controversy, and inhumanity" that you briefly touch upon. By delving deeper into these concepts, you can further highlight the stark contrast between the idealized vision of freedom and the harsh realities that exist. Additionally, incorporating specific examples or anecdotes would lend even more weight to your argument.
  
  Overall, this is a compelling and thought-provoking poem that encourages readers to question and critically examine the concept of freedom. Great job! more »

  LikeReply3 months ago